Senior Counsel to face attempted murder charge after failed bid to overturn NPA decision
The High Court in Pretoria has found there are “reasonable and probable grounds” to prosecute Adv. Roelof du Plessis, Senior Counsel (SC), for his role in a 2023 road rage incident that left his alleged victim, Conrad Pretorius, with gaping knife wounds to his neck and thigh. The court further rejected Du Plessis’ claim that the decision to prosecute him was the result of pressure from AfriForum’s Private Prosecution Unit, which represents the complainant (Pretorius). Judge Sulet Potterill delivered her judgment last week, hopefully bringing an end to more than a year of legal wrangling by Du Plessis to avoid having his day in court.
The case was argued on 6 August 2026. AfriForum was not a party to Du Plessis’s application against the office of the National Director of Public Prosecutions (NDPP), but its outcome has a direct bearing on the Unit’s client.
In August 2025, the NPA decided to charge Du Plessis with attempted murder following successful representations by the Unit. The NPA had initially charged Pretorius with assault and malicious damage to property, but reconsidered its decision following the Unit’s representations on his behalf. In a well-considered response, Adv. Shamila Batohi, the erstwhile NDPP, said Du Plessis must be prosecuted for attempted murder. “The central issue in this matter is who acted unlawfully in attacking whom and in this regard, whether Adv. Du Plessis acted in private defence when he twice stabbed Mr. Pretorius with his pocketknife,” she said.
“It is my considered view that the prima facie evidence and the probabilities emerging from the case as a whole show that Adv. Du Plessis did not act in private defence when he attacked Mr. Pretorius with the knife, and indeed, that Adv. Du Plessis acted unlawfully when he twice stabbed Mr. Pretorius. Furthermore, the nature of the stab-wounds inflicted on Mr. Pretorius prima facie show that Adv. Du Plessis committed the crime of attempted murder when he stabbed Mr. Pretorius,” reasoned Batohi.
Potterill, in her judgment last week, was asked to determine whether Batohi’s decision to prosecute Du Plessis instead of Pretorius was objectively rational based on the facts. “Du Plessis used a knife to fend off, on his version, an unarmed man who was attacking him, and he caused serious injuries in doing so. Du Plessis’ medical report reflects little injuries to himself. The intentional use of a knife when the attacker is weapon-less are rational facts upon which Batoyi could decide. The wounds were on the neck and upper thigh giving rise to an inference of dolus eventualis being present in respect of attempted murder. I am satisfied that the decision was objectively rational and related to the purpose for which the power was granted,” said Potterill in her judgment.
The Unit’s spokesperson, Barry Bateman, says they welcome the judgment and acknowledge the well-reasoned arguments presented by the NPA’s counsel, Adv. Nazeer Cassim SC, and the team from the Office of the State Attorney. “Judge Potterill has confirmed what the Unit has said from the beginning, that Adv. Du Plessis has a case to answer. Our client and ourselves specifically note the finding that, on Du Plessis’ own version there are reasonable and probable cause to prosecute him, and that former NDPP Adv. Batohi’s decision that Du Plessis, rather than Pretorius, should be prosecuted was objectively rational.
“The Unit further welcomes the finding that AfriForum’s outspoken views on the case did not cause Batohi to act with bias when she made her decision. This office has always simply asked the NPA to act without fear, favour or prejudice, in accordance with its duty, and we believe that this was done in this case. We will now await the NPA’s initiation of criminal proceedings and ensure that Pretorius, the complainant, is ready to testify,” says Bateman.
Bateman says the Unit will continue its engagements with the NPA, not only in relation to this matter but also regarding the separate crimen injuria cases against politicians Fikile Mbalula and Julius Malema. The state has decided to prosecute both politicians in the Johannesburg Magistrate’s Court on charges arising from the Jaco Pieterse matters.
BACKGROUND
The case relates to an incident on 1 August 2023, where Pretorius and his wife were driving in Menlo Park in Pretoria and they encountered Du Plessis, who is a member of advocates chambers in Pretoria, at an intersection where the traffic lights were not working. It is alleged that an altercation ensued which resulted in Du Plessis chasing Pretorius through the streets of the suburb for about five kilometres before allegedly blocking him in a cul de sac. It is further alleged that Pretorius and Du Plessis alighted from their vehicles where a confrontation occurred. Pretorius alleges that Du Plessis stabbed him in the neck with a sharp object, whereafter a struggle ensued, and he was also stabbed in his leg. Pretorius managed to get back in his car and drove to the nearest hospital for treatment.
Pretorius was hospitalised with life threatening injuries. While in the hospital, he filed a criminal complaint for attempted murder against Du Plessis, only to discover that the advocate had also filed a criminal complaint against him.



