AfriForum urges Mothibi to end delays in Mbalula and Malema cases
When will a date be set for Fikile Mbalula and Julius Malema to make their first court appearances? That’s the question AfriForum’s Private Prosecution Unit has put to Adv. Andy Mothibi, National Director of Public Prosecutions, in a letter. Last month – thus, before the elections – the Unit confirmed that the ANC secretary-general and EFF leader, respectively, had been served with summonses to appear in the Johannesburg Magistrate’s Court on charges of crimen injuria in relation to the case of Jaco Pieterse, former Bergview College Principal. However, the summonses were held back after the pair submitted representations to Mothibi. Now, the Unit, which represents Pieterse, has asked Mothibi when the representations will be finalised and when the pair will be served with summonses to appear in court.
In correspondence to Mothibi, Adv. Gerrie Nel, head of AfriForum’s Private Prosecution Unit, says the Unit recognises a suspect’s constitutional right to make representations and to seek reconsideration of a prosecutorial decision. “We equally acknowledge the duty of the prosecution authority to consider such representations fairly and objectively. However, we respectfully emphasise that the alleged offences date back to 2025 and that the harm and prejudice suffered by our client are ongoing. The continued uncertainty surrounding the prosecution of this matter serves only to prolong that prejudice.
“We are also mindful of the prevailing political climate and the fact that both Mbalula and Malema occupy prominent positions in public and political life. It is precisely in circumstances such as these that the independence, impartiality and consistency of prosecutorial decision-making become particularly important. A decision not to prosecute, or an unreasonable delay in reaching a final decision, may create a perception that persons holding positions of political influence are afforded different treatment from ordinary members of the public. Such a perception, whether justified or not, has the potential to undermine public confidence in the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) and the administration of justice,” said Nel.
Mbalula and Malema face charges of crimen injuria for falsely branding Pieterse a child rapist. In relation to Mbalula, the Gauteng Director of Public Prosecutions, Adv. Andrew Chauke, correctly rejected the suspect’s representations and informed his legal team that his office was of the view that a prima facie case existed against Mbalula and that the matter should be enrolled for adjudication before a competent court.
Chauke further correctly rejected the suspect’s baseless allegation that the case was politically motivated, informing his legal team that his office had thoroughly studied the criminal case docket and had based its decision on legal principles and facts. He stated confidently that there was no political influence and/or motivation attached to the decision.
The Unit has urged Mothibi to urgently respond to the correspondence and to ensure that the matters are enrolled for prosecution without further delay.



